« Digital Rights Management (DRM) and CRM | Main | Retail customer experience management »
Saturday
Feb102007

US Unilateralism -- Beyond Putin's Comments

Romance at the Metropol in Moscow
Russian President Vladimir Putin recently said that the United States' execution of foreign policy is a major motivation behind smaller countries pursuing nuclear ambitions. Some in the US called the speech provocative and confontational. According to the BBC, 'Mr Putin's spokesman Dimitry Peskov said the speech was "not about confrontation, it's an invitation to think. Until we get rid of unilateralism in international affairs, until we exclude the possibility of imposing one country's views on others, we will not have stability,' he said.

No matter what you think of US foreign policy and Mr. Putin, there's a business lesson or two here if you look for parallels between policy unilateralism and a business strategy that attempts to "impose" a value proposition on global markets. Wal-Mart just got drummed out of Germany. In my view, the two biggest reasons were:

1. Wal-Mart didn't appreciate the resistance it would receive from its competitors, who already form a very tight economic ecosystem there. Once any ecosystem evolves to the point that everyone's got a defensible niche, new entrants just have a terrible time finding their place.

2. Wal-Mart didn't appreciate that its branded format for customer experiences was, in the eyes of Germans, silly. Germans don't want to be greeted at the door with a friendly face. They want to shop. It's not that Germans don't want a relationship with businesses, either. It's the style, the approach, the -- well, face it, the American way of being glibly welcoming.

There's an opportunity here for business. As you go into international markets, focus like a laser on how these markets perceive your contribution to THEIR economic and cultural ecosystems. You may find that the thing that's bankable in some markets has zero -- or even negative -- value in others.

Then, deconstruct what you offer and repackage it based on what you learn. New products, new experiences -- new profits.

INSEAD's Yves Doz talks a lot about this. Email me if you've run into this challenge, and let me know how you approached it.

As for whether this business observation has a parallel to global politics, let me go out on a limb to say that the US should in fact be really aware of how its actions affect its allies and enemies. It's mainly through this understanding -- and concomitant diplomacy -- that we can have a credible brand in the world. I'm not suggesting the US is up to no good, as Putin implies. We do a lot of good, and can do more. But our brand is not just about whether we're good or bad. That's way too simplistic, in a world of interlocking interests in the areas of global warming, energy sourcing, labor arbitrage, human rights, poverty and regional conflicts. It's hard work getting it right.

Note on the picture above: This statue is one of many lovely details of the legendary Metropol Hotel in Moscow. I enjoyed my stay there recently and recommend it.

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>